The Research-Practice Gap

(Evidence-practice gap) in SSD speech therapy

Want to stay informed?

Kate Beckett Ultimate Speech Sounds research-practice gap also known as the evidence-practice gap

Challenges Facing SLPs Treating Children with Speech Sound Disorders - The Research-Practice Gap

Speech-Language Pathologists (SLPs) play a critical role in helping children with Speech Sound Disorders (SSD) develop clear communication skills. However, the field faces significant challenges, including long waiting lists, high caseloads, and administrative burdens. Additionally, the research-practice gap (also known as the evidence-practice gap) poses a major hurdle in consistently delivering evidence-based practice (EBP). These obstacles impact not only SLPs but also the children who require timely and intensive intervention.

Speech Therapy has long waiting lists around the world as reported in the research-practice gap

High Demand, Long Waiting Lists, and Missed Opportunities for Early Intervention

The demand for Speech-Language Pathology (SLP) services has increased sharply, leading to long waiting lists worldwide. These delays put children at risk of missing critical windows for early intervention, essential for speech and language development (Leaf et al., 2024; McLeod et al., 2022; Just et al., 2020). Many SLPs express frustration, describing these waiting lists as “disgusting,” reflecting the harm caused to children in need (Edgar et al., 2007).

This issue highlights the research-practice gap, or evidence-practice gap, which delays the implementation of evidence-based practices (EBP). Early intervention is vital. Research shows that delaying therapy until ages 4-5 significantly lowers the chances of achieving normalized speech outcomes (Rvachew & Rafaat, 2014). Missing the critical window for intensive therapy can lead to long-term consequences. These include poorer academic performance, mental health struggles, and difficulties in social relationships and future opportunities (Cohrssen et al., 2023; Just et al., 2020; McLeod, 2018).

Without timely, evidence-based intervention, children face ongoing communication issues, reduced school success, and challenges in forming friendships. These effects often persist into adulthood, affecting careers, emotional well-being, and overall health (McGill et al., 2020). Closing the research-practice gap is essential to ensure children receive the timely and effective care they need.

Join our Journal Club for SLPs

Name

The Lasting Impact of Persistent SSD on Academic, Social, and Emotional Outcomes

Persistent Speech Sound Disorders (SSD) can significantly affect a child’s life, impacting more than just communication. McLeod et al. (2022) found that if SSD persists beyond preschool, 30-77% of children may develop reading difficulties. These challenges compound their struggles in school and social settings. Additionally, up to 25% of children with speech and language difficulties also have reading disorders (Tambyraja et al., 2020). These issues hinder academic success and lower long-term educational outcomes (McLeod et al., 2022).

The research-practice gap, or delay in applying evidence to clinical care, worsens these problems. Children often miss timely, effective interventions. Untreated SSD is linked to poor performance in subjects like English, especially between ages 10 and 14 (Hegarty et al., 2018). These challenges can escalate. In 2021, 9% of 14-21-year-olds who dropped out of school had a speech or language impairment (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2024). Bridging the research-practice gap is critical to providing early, intensive intervention and preventing SSD from derailing children’s educational and social development.

Long-term impact on missing speech therapy research-practice gap
Long-term impact on missing speech therapy research-practice gap

The Lasting Impact of Persistent SSD on Academic, Social, and Emotional Outcomes

Persistent Speech Sound Disorders (SSD) can significantly affect a child’s life, impacting more than just communication. McLeod et al. (2022) found that if SSD persists beyond preschool, 30-77% of children may develop reading difficulties. These challenges compound their struggles in school and social settings. Additionally, up to 25% of children with speech and language difficulties also have reading disorders (Tambyraja et al., 2020). These issues hinder academic success and lower long-term educational outcomes (McLeod et al., 2022).

The research-practice gap, or delay in applying evidence to clinical care, worsens these problems. Children often miss timely, effective interventions. Untreated SSD is linked to poor performance in subjects like English, especially between ages 10 and 14 (Hegarty et al., 2018). These challenges can escalate. In 2021, 9% of 14-21-year-olds who dropped out of school had a speech or language impairment (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2024). Bridging the research-practice gap is critical to providing early, intensive intervention and preventing SSD from derailing children’s educational and social development.

SLP caseload management is difficult evidence-practice gap

Managing Caseloads and Addressing Service Shortfalls

Children with Speech Sound Disorders (SSD) make up a large part of Speech-Language Pathologists’ (SLPs) caseloads. In 2022, 92% of SLPs reported treating children with SSD (ASHA, 2022). SSD is also the second most common disability in children aged 3 to 5, making up 34% of disabilities in this group (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2024). Over half of the 3.4 million children served under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) need SLP support, showing the high demand for speech therapy (Suh et al., 2024).

Despite this demand, the research-practice gap creates major barriers to effective care. Over 54% of SLPs describe their caseloads as “unmanageable” (Marante et al., 2023). Many provide only one session per week, despite research showing 2-3 sessions per week are needed for progress (Hegarty et al., 2018). Large caseloads also lead to shorter sessions and fewer practice trials than the recommended 50-100 per session (Sugden et al., 2018). These limitations often result in ineffective therapy outcomes (Alighieri et al., 2021). Bridging the research-practice gap is essential to ensure children with SSD receive the frequency and intensity of therapy needed for lasting success.

Home practice and Parental Involvement: Essential but Challenging Components of Therapy

Home practice is crucial for reinforcing speech therapy techniques between sessions. Tambyraja (2020) found that 95% of SLPs assign home practice, but 56% do not consistently follow up. Logistical challenges make tracking completion and quality difficult. This lack of follow-up highlights an evidence-practice gap, as research shows consistent, high-intensity practice is key for effective outcomes (Gunther & Hautvast, 2010).

Parental involvement is also hard to facilitate. Many parents feel unprepared or lack confidence in using therapy techniques at home (Sugden et al., 2018). Without proper support, children miss the full benefits of home practice, which is essential for progress (McKechnie et al., 2018). Addressing this evidence-practice gap requires innovative solutions. These tools should help SLPs track and guide home practice while empowering parents to stay engaged in their child’s therapy.

speech therapy evidence-practice gap
speech therapy evidence-practice gap

Home practice and Parental Involvement: Essential but Challenging Components of Therapy

Home practice is crucial for reinforcing speech therapy techniques between sessions. Tambyraja (2020) found that 95% of SLPs assign home practice, but 56% do not consistently follow up. Logistical challenges make tracking completion and quality difficult. This lack of follow-up highlights an evidence-practice gap, as research shows consistent, high-intensity practice is key for effective outcomes (Gunther & Hautvast, 2010).

Parental involvement is also hard to facilitate. Many parents feel unprepared or lack confidence in using therapy techniques at home (Sugden et al., 2018). Without proper support, children miss the full benefits of home practice, which is essential for progress (McKechnie et al., 2018). Addressing this evidence-practice gap requires innovative solutions. These tools should help SLPs track and guide home practice while empowering parents to stay engaged in their child’s therapy.

Paperwork and admin burden in speech pathology reported in the research-practice gap also known as the evidence-practice gap

The Administrative Burden on SLPs and Its Impact on Service Quality

A major challenge for SLPs is the time-consuming administrative workload. Tasks like session documentation, progress reports, and creating individualized plans often take as much time as therapy itself. In fact, 47% of SLPs spend over seven hours weekly on administrative tasks (Edgar et al., 2007). This paperwork is widely disliked, with 42.1% of SLPs naming it their least favorite part of the job (McLeod & Baker, 2014).

The extensive time spent on administration reduces the ability to provide frequent, high-quality therapy. Balancing large caseloads with these demands also leads to high turnover. As a result, 65% of SLPs report they are likely to leave their position due to workload and caseload pressures (Marante et al., 2023).

The Importance of Evidence-Based Therapy and the Difficulty of Delivering It

Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) shows that children with SSD benefit from high-frequency, high-dosage therapy sessions (Alighieri et al., 2021). SLPs frequently use techniques such as speech discrimination (79.5%), minimal pairs (77.3%), and phonological awareness (75.6%) to treat phonological impairments (Hegarty et al., 2018). However, delivering frequent sessions at the recommended dose is challenging due to current caseloads and service delivery models (Sugden et al., 2018).

Research suggests 2-3 sessions per week with 50-100 trials per session. However, most SLPs cannot meet this standard (McKechnie et al., 2018).. About 69% of SLPs report providing therapy only once per week (Hegarty et al., 2018). With limited resources and heavy caseloads, many SLPs struggle to deliver therapy that meets EBP standards. This often results in lower intervention intensity, which may lead to limited progress for children (Alighieri et al., 2021).

Read more about Evidence-Based Practice HERE.

SLP research-practice gap is reported in the evidence-based practice research articles.
SLP research-practice gap is reported in the evidence-based practice research articles.

The Importance of Evidence-Based Therapy and the Difficulty of Delivering It

Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) shows that children with SSD benefit from high-frequency, high-dosage therapy sessions (Alighieri et al., 2021). SLPs frequently use techniques such as speech discrimination (79.5%), minimal pairs (77.3%), and phonological awareness (75.6%) to treat phonological impairments (Hegarty et al., 2018). However, delivering frequent sessions at the recommended dose is challenging due to current caseloads and service delivery models (Sugden et al., 2018).

Research suggests 2-3 sessions per week with 50-100 trials per session. However, most SLPs cannot meet this standard (McKechnie et al., 2018).. About 69% of SLPs report providing therapy only once per week (Hegarty et al., 2018). With limited resources and heavy caseloads, many SLPs struggle to deliver therapy that meets EBP standards. This often results in lower intervention intensity, which may lead to limited progress for children (Alighieri et al., 2021).

Read more about Evidence-Based Practice HERE.

SSD effects children's careers reported in the also known as the evidence-practice gap

Long-Term Implications of Untreated or Late-Treated SSD

Delayed or insufficient intervention for SSD has far-reaching consequences. If unresolved by age 5, SSD often persists as children enter school. By age 8, 3.6% of children still show persistent SSD, with little chance of spontaneous improvement (Wren et al., 2021).

Persistent SSD is linked to poorer academic performance, especially in reading and language-heavy subjects like English. It affects school success through ages 10 to 14 (Hegarty et al., 2018). Untreated SSD also harms social and emotional development. It limits future educational and vocational opportunities (Cohrssen et al., 2023; Just et al., 2020; McLeod, 2018). Without early intervention, children are at higher risk of long-term difficulties in communication, social interactions, and education.

These challenges highlight the critical role SLPs play in addressing SSD early.

Conclusion: Supporting SLPs in Overcoming These Challenges

SLPs face many challenges in treating children with SSD. These include unmanageable caseloads, administrative burdens, and difficulties in delivering evidence-based, high-intensity therapy. Solutions are urgently needed to streamline administrative tasks, improve access to timely services, and increase parent engagement in home practice. Addressing these issues is crucial to support SLPs. It ensures children with SSD develop the communication skills needed for academic success, social connections, and future opportunities.

Stay in touch

References

A

Alighieri, C., van Lierde, K., de Caesemaeker, A., Demuynck, K., Bruneel, L., D’haeseleer, E. and Bettens, K. (2021) “Is High-Intensity Speech Intervention Better? A Comparison of High-Intensity Intervention Versus Low-Intensity Intervention in Children with a Cleft Palate”, Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 64, 3398-3415

ASHA (2022) “Schools Survey Report: SLP Caseload Characteristics Trends 2004-2022”, Accessed August 28th 2024 at https://www.asha.org/siteassets/surveys/2022-schools-survey-caseload-characteristics-trends.pdf

B
C

Cohrssen, C., Richards, B. and Wang, R. (2023) “Using Smartphones to Disseminate Home Learning Support to Primary Caregivers: An Exploratory Proof-of-Concept Study”, Infant and Child Development, 32: e2399

D
E

Edgar, D. L. and Rosa-Lugo (2007) “The Critical Shortage of Speech-Language Pathologists in the Public School Setting: Features of the Work Environment That Affect Recruitment and Retention”, Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in School, 38, 31-46

F
G

Gunther, T. and Hautvast, S. (2010), “Addition of Contingency Management to Increase Home Practice in Young Children with a Speech Sound Disorder”, International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders, 45(3), 345-353

H

Hegarty, N., Titterington, J., McLeod, S. and Taggart, L. (2018) “Intervention for Children with Phonological Impairment: Knowledge, Practices and Intervention Intensity in the UK”, International Journal of Language and Communication, 53, 995-1006

I
J

Just, E., Pearce, W. M. and Crosbie, S. (2020) “Pathways to Paediatric Speech Pathology Services in Australia”, Speech, Language and Hearing, 25:2, 192-203

K
L

Leafe, N., Pagnamenta, E., Taggart, L., Donnelly, M., Hassiotis, A. and Titterington, J. (2024), “What Works, How and in Which Contexts When Supporting parents to Implement Intensive Speech and Language Therapy at Home for Children with Speech Sound Disorder? A Protocol for a Realist Review”, BMJ Open, 14: e074272

M

Marante, L., Hall-Mills, S. and Farquharson, K. (2023) “School-Based Speech-Language Pathologists’ Stress and Burnout: A Cross-Sectional Survey at the Height of the COVID-19 Pandemic”, Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in School, 54, 456-471

McGill, N., Crowe, K. and McLeod, S. (2020) “Many Wasted Months”: Stakeholders’ Perspectives About Waiting for Speech-Language Pathology Services, International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 22:3, 313-326

McKechnie, J., Ahmed, B., Gutierrez-Osuna, R., Monroe, P., McCabe, P. and Ballard, K. J. (2018) “Automated Speech Analysis Tools for Children’s Speech Production Systematic Literature Review”, International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 20, 583-598

McLeod, S., Ballard, K., Ahmed, B., McGill, N. and Brown, M. L. (2022) “Supporting Children with Speech Sound Disorders During COVID-19 Restrictions: Technological Solutions”, Perspectives of the ASHA Special Interest Groups, 5, 1805-1808

McLeod, S. (2018) “Communication Rights: Fundamental Human Rights for All“, International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 20(1), 3-11

McLeod, S. and Baker, E. (2014) “Speech-Language Pathologists’ Practices Regarding Assessment, Analysis, Target Selection, Intervention, and Service Delivery for Children with Speech Sound Disorders”, Clinical Linguistics & Phonetics, 28:7-8, 508-531

N
O
P
Q
R

Rvachew, S. and Rafaat, S. (2014) “Report on Benchmark Wait Times for Pediatric Speech Sound Disorders”, Canadian Journal of Speech-Language Pathology and Audiology, 38, 82-96

S

Sugden, E., Baker, E., Munro, N., Williams, L. and Trivette, C. M. (2018) “An Australian Survey of Parent Involvement in Intervention for Childhood Speech Sound Disorders”, International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 20:7, 766-778

Suh, H., Dangol, A., Meadan-Kaplansky, H., Miller, C. A. and Kientz, J. A. (2024) “Opportunities and Challenges for AI-Based Support for Speech-Language Pathologists”, In Proceedings of the 3rd Annual Meeting of the Symposium on Human-Computer Interaction for Work (CHIWORK ’24), June 25-27, 2024, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom. ACM, New York, NY, USA

T

Tambyraja, S. R., Farquharson, K. and Justice, L. M. (2020) “Reading Risk in Children with Speech Sound Disorder: Prevalence, Persistence, and Predictors”, Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 63, 3714-3726

Tambyraja, S. R. (2020) “Facilitating Parental Involvement in Speech Therapy for Children with Speech Sound Disorders: A Survey of Speech-Language Pathologists’ Practices, Perspectives, and Strategies”, American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 29, 1987-1996

U

U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2024) “Occupational Outlook Handbook: Speech-Language Pathologists”, Accessed July 10th 2024 at https://www.bls.gov/ooh/healthcare/speech-language-pathologists.htm#:~:text=Employment%20of%20speech%2Dlanguage%20pathologists,on%20average%2C%20over%20the%20decade

V
W

Wren, Y., Pagnamenta, E., Peters, T., Emond, A., Northstone, K., Miller, L. and Roulstone, S. (2021) “Educational Outcomes Associated with Persistent Speech Disorder”, International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders, 56, 299-312

X
Y
Z